iv been on forza series 1 2 and now 3 with the 360, love it, the driving feel to me on forza is better than gt, graphics have always been on the improve each time, havent had any big delays with things being released. driving sounds are amazing, and as said as your car progressively tunes up the sounds change. a lot of attention to this and each cars actual sound.
i played my mates gt5 tonight, and being totally unbias as i too was possibly going to buy a ps3 for gt5 and metal gear solid. im not as impressed as i should be for a game thats taken something like 3 years to be released!!
yes the go karting is cool! the nascar racing is different and sound amazing, im told theres f1 cars? but didnt have too much time to explore...what i did get to see is enough to get 3 career cars. got an evo 4 and started buying the odd bit for it...have to say im not as happy as i was hoping to be with the upgrades and tuning side of things. i was expecting it to be so finely detailed that you could alter boost pressures etc, didnt find any of that, even after turbo modifications.
one thing i am very impressed with is the small fine details that forza doesnt have...the thing i have wanted and wanted with forza is the icing on the cake to exhaust bangs etc, plenty pops and bangs on forza, especially those v8 supercars, but no flame, not even a spit...the gt5 exhaust flames in the more powerful cars, nascar and race cars are amazing...not worth buying the game for obviously lol but i loved it, they are stunning, big small quick long
the rain effects are superb too, especially in car view and how you alter low or high beam affects vision etc. i could see me buying gt5 if i had a ps3, getting so far with it and after a few weeks of good gaming getting left in the drawer under the tv
forza since day one has never really had any dry phases with me where iv not played it, even when new games have been released like cod mw2 and medal of honour, iv played them hard too, but i can still slip on forza for some battles on or offline. never really been bored of it
if i was to sum things up, i think both games are good. i still think forza has the edge on the realism to driving. theres more to do on gt5 yeah, but for a game with such a long delay on release its crying out for more i think
the perfect game in my opinion would be forzas driving, a combination of both forza and gt5 graphics, and tracks, gt5s vast different races to takepart in such as rally, karting, nascar etc, and gt5s attention to fine fussy details.
as someone who has liked modifying cars, and epecially now works in this feild, i would demand a higher amount of things to do and purchase from both games on the modifying front, games like these demand so much more from this side of the game